KARE 11 Extra/Ethanol: Fuel of our Future?
last night, KARE 11 ran a report on the misnomer ethanol is the fuel of our future and will break our nation's dependancy on foreign oil. here are some facts from the report:• most Americans are not putting ethanol in their tanks. ethanol accounts for 3.5% of the fuel used in the nation
• minnesota is home to 25% of the E85 pumps in the nation (of the 1,259 E85 pumps in America, 312 are in minnesota)
• this year's corn crop covered almost 93 million acres of farm land, a 19% increase from last year
• in minnesota alone, ethanol plants will produce 620 million gallons of E85
• projected for 2008: 1 billion gallons
question: if most car drivers aren't ASKING for ethanol, if most cars are not engineered to RUN on ethanol, and if top foreign car makers honda and toyota don't currently sell ANY cars in the US designed to handle high blends of ethanol, why are producers producing so MUCH ethanol?
answer: because the government is PUSHING ethanol.
sound bite from MN governor tim pawlenty: "It is not good for our country as a matter of national security to have that much of our country's future hooked to people who don't like us or want to do us harm."
fact: the top two sources of foreign oil brought to America are canada and mexico. saudi arabia is the only country in the top 5 suppliers located in the persian gulf area.
sound bite from david tillman, university of minnesota ecologist: "If we took all the corn we grew in 2005 in the whole United States and used that to make ethanol, it would only get rid of 12% of our gasoline."
yet, the government is spending taxpayer money on ethanol as though it is the ONLY solution.
• in minnesota, farmers received nearly $376 million in ethanol subsidies since the 1980's
• in the whole country, $14 billion in tax credits over the next four years
sound bite from ford runge, university of minnesota economist: "the american ethanol industry subsidies are a reflection of its relative inefficiency compared to lower-cost ethanol sources such as sugarcane-based ethanol from brazil."
take away the subsidies, and there would be NO market for ethanol made from corn.
ford runge: "the ethanol industry is the creation of government subsidies."
runge co-authored an article in Foreign Affairs and notes corn prices have surged because of ethanol. in march, corn futures hit their highest level in 10 years. read the article titled "How Biofuels Could Starve The Poor" here.
ford runge: "we are filling the tanks of our vehicles with ethanol fuels that are bidding corn away from food uses."
producing ethanol also has environmental concerns.
• it takes 4.2 gallons of water to produce just 1 gallon of ethanol
the amount of energy that goes into MAKING ethanol is almost as large as the amount of energy ethanol produces.
dave tillman: "20% of the energy in a gallon of ethanol is new energy. 80% is all the energy it took to grow the corn and convert the corn into ethanol. and that energy it took was fossil energy. in the long term, corn's not going to do it for us."
considering what i wrote yesterday on GM and the EV1 electric car, i found this interesting: GM makes more than 1/3 of E85 cars on the road today. it appears, quite clearly, which puppet the government has on the end of its strings.
although i provided most of the facts in the report above, watch the video for yourself.
2 Comments:
So, SOMEONE has a perspective on ethanol??? =)
I agree.
Actually, some of the most interesting things I've heard on the subject are from David Tillman. He's currently working (at the U of M, I believe) on research regarding the use of native/restored prairie biomass as fuel. He believes (and has quite convincing evidence to demonstrate) that it's much more promising because it doesn't require turning food crops into fuel...and it requires FAR FEWER inputs (fertilizer, irrigation, herbicides, etc.). Instead, the restored prairie areas on marginal/edge lands that are already protected by conservation easements, the Reinvest in Minnesota program, etc. could be harvested, shredded and used as fuel. It's emerging technology, but I have to admit that I much prefer the thought of that to the thought of turning food into fuel. Besides, it wouldn't rely solely on one type of crop.
So, no, my next car won't run on E85...
i agree that it would be a very good idea to find an alternative fuel source to oil. even if politicians weren't swimming in it. even if there was an endless supply. it still makes good sense to find another source.
i'm especially keen to the idea that it be something more than corn. i like the tillman thoughts that budori pointed out. i hope the technology proves to be as promising as it sounds.
Post a Comment
<< Home